Would not recommend this mascara. I bought it because the price was cheap and the mascara said waterproof. After applying to my lashes it gave it some volume and I was happy. End of the day comes, I decided it was time to take it off with my micellar water, it did not work. I used make up wipes, it did not work, I used olive oil and it still DID NOT REMOVE ANY OF THE MASCARA! I was so upset because a couple days later my lashes were still clumped together and the mascara residue was still on. Took a long time to get this mascara off, therefore I have to give this a thumbs down.