This eyeliner stays on and does not smudge, it is three dollars in Canada and definitely worth the price.

I love essence products and I decided to try this one out and honestly, its an okay product. I don't love it because it would dry out so quickly after applying eyeliner on just one eye and it doesn't stay on for long, it smudges quickly. Since I've used this product already I use it on my eyebrows now and sometimes to shape them because the eyeliner is dry even though I just brought it. I wouldn't really recommend this product to people but you guys can try it since its just $4

I loved using this pen, once I got the hang of it. Just a little pricey for what it was.

I like to use eyeliner for everyday of the week, except for the occasional lazy days. This Essence eyeliner pen was a great find price wise, but average for use. The first couple applications of the product was good, went on smooth and gave good definition, which is something I look for. But afterwards, when I applied it, it was dull and just lost its vibe lol. Anyways, good for how much it costs so if I was completely out of luck and broke but need something to work with, then this would be my choice..

This is an ok eyeliner. I appreciate how small the tip is and how sturdy the end is. I think its a good eyeliner pen for beginners of eyeliner because of how much control you have with this. This is not waterproof, and will run with water, tears or rain. This also can smudge.

I got this as a free sample at the mall and it was definitely an upgrade from my super expensive high end liquid liner. The pen was easy to use and it is waterproof and smudge proof and I can vouch for it. You would need a very hard smudgee to smudge this eyeliner. Cat eye look was very easy to accomplish also.

Not a bad eyeliner for a drugstore brand. It doesn't smudge at all like they claim and goes on smoothly, evenly. It's a great liner for basic, subtle application. However, if you like a thick and really bold look you have to go over and over quite a lot for it to show up. Otherwise I was really impressed with the quality for it's cheap price!