Transfers like crazy

I had high hopes for this, since I love Essence's other eyeliners.
I wanted a waterproof eyeliner to wear in summer, and this is not it.

The pen goes on smoothly, dries quickly and is a lovely solid black. I haven't experienced any stinging in my eyes that other waterproof liners have given me in the past. Plus, it's super inexpensive.

Maybe I got a bad one, but it is totally not waterproof. If my eyes are watery due to allergies, It wears off quickly, and I find that it transfers on my eyelid worse than the regular eyeliners. I get big grey smudges on my eyelid after a couple of hours.