This liquid liner has an awesome sponge aplicator. I love the way the formula goes on and it's pretty opaque so no need to reapply a bunch of times. The biggest downfall to this liner is that it dries out on your eyes and flakes off so easily! It looks awesome when you put it on but within an hour it starts flaking off. Definitely doesn't have the durability of a liquid liner I need.

I was not into this at all. The product was very sticky, and where it hit my eyelashes they stuck together and i had to pry them apart. Also, the small little wand made it harder to apply and the shape was weird.