Using it wrong?

I purchased this product because I heard it was very similar to the Benefit one and it had such a great price point I thought why not. I recently went to use it and was not impressed. It made my brow hairs feel wet and were very dark. There was only two shades so of course with how dark my real brows are I chose the darker one. I may have used it too heavy but I immediately took it off and used my go to brow products.