Not Mistake Proof

I recieved this eyeliner in my Ipsy bag. I was excited to try it out since it was a liquid liner. The colour is a rich carbon black; fresh out of box the colour is rich and opaque. That is where the excitement ends. The tip is too thick so it is very difficult to get a fine precise line. The product dries quickly so you have to have a steady and experienced hand when applying. I also found that the product bleeds causing the line to become messy. The product dries quickly so you have to have a steady and experienced hand when applying. After many attempts, messing up my eye makup, and reapplying I finally got a decent look. About halfway through the day I found the product became cracked and flaky. The product claims to be waterproof but it is not. Not tear-proof and heaven forbid don't get caught in a downpour like I did. The liner ran and smudged. So bottom line not worth the frustration. I expect that a 22.00US be better.