The Garnier BB Eye definitely had much more coverage power than the Anti-Dark Circle Eye Roller. When I first rolled it on, I thought it would be just as watery and sheer, but when I started blending it out I noticed it had a thicker, bordering on creamy consistency that covered more of my dark circles without the caking I sometimes experience with concealer. My under eyes also stayed hydrated all day. I definitely prefer the BB Eye to the Anti-Dark Circle Eye Roller as I feel I am finally getting some decent coverage from an eye roll-on as well as experiencing the pleasure of the cold metal rollerball on my face. I’ve been using it under BB Cream and I feel I at least look slightly less corpse-like.

I was skeptical about purchasing this item because I use Garnier's regular under eye roll on concealer and liked it very much already. Plus this new one has less ml of product in it for the same price as the regular one. So I waited til it was on sale and gave it a try. Firstly, it has better coverage then the original for the blueness under your eyes without being heavy still. It stayed on nicely all day and took away my morning puffiness. All in all it's about the same as the original but with heavier coverage if you have bad under eye circles. (without weighing on your skin) All I can complain about is 'Hey give us more product for our buck!' ;) Although a little does go a long way..

I really enjoyed this product, I found it takes away the purple and puffiness in the morning. great pair with my concealer!

I love Garnier products for under my eyes. It's very refreshing and light, the consistency is quite liquid which makes it easier to roll on and dab in place without tugging under my eyes which is important! Unlike other under eye rollers, this one nourishes and softens the area and is very gentle.