Great for all day wear

I knew before I bought this that I like felt tip applicators for eyeliner. So I went into this purchase with a positive mindset. I was not disappointed. It applies easily and the colour last me the entire day. I had even touched my eyes a couples times and it didn’t smudge. The only downside for me is that it can dry out, but that’s a quick fix with a press on paper towel.

Easy, but smudgy.

This is the best pen-eyeliner I've found. It has a nice thin tip, perfect for wings. It doesn't get too clogged up/dried out from going over eye shadow, it's super easy to apply and doesn't take 20 minutes and a real steady hand. My only problem is that it is very smudgy. Once the eyeliner is dried, it can easily be removed or smudged. I mean, it makes it easier to remove at the end of the day, you're not having to scrub your eyelid off, but I have smudged it by accident from just wiping near my eye. Still the best I've found and I recommend to everyone!

Worst bleeding liner

I got this liner because my other one was not in stock but it was horrible. Well putting this on my top lid the top of the felt tip kept breaking off chunks of black as I went then it was bleeding down into my lashes and just a horrible mess. I re applied multiple times but it looked like I didn't put any on, like a water soluble marker. This is definitely one of the worst liners I have ever tried.

Not good

I got this for Christmas and of course i messed up my eye liner. I went to wipe it off and it smeared all over my face I could not get it off even with makeup remover. It goes on nicely but it does not come off nicely. It is too much liquid.

Comparable to Kay Von D's Tattoo Eye Liner!

My go too liquid eye liner! Buy this on the regular. It is water and smudge proof. It dries up quickly but It's affordable so there's no worry about having to pop into Walmart to purchase a new one.