I received this product to try and its pretty good quality. it goes on nice a dark, creamy base. It lasted me almost all day if I was to go out at night I might need to do a slight touch up. However this product just isn't for me because I'm horrible at applying these type of eyeliners and I get them wrong more often then I get them right. You really have to be precise. I don't know how some girls do it. I think I will stick to my good ol original pen liners.