Great, smudge proof, waterproof, cheap!

It does it all and on a shoe string budget! This eyeliner was bought for 5 dollars on impulse at Shoppers Drug Mart, I used it in my car with the little flip down mirror panel and instantly said "Oooo..."

It's *dark* and striking and very vibrant. As I've run lower it's gotten clearer which sucks so it gets 3/5 for quality. But it's lasted over a year.

It will take soap to come off and if your eyes water like mine it'll stay long provided you can keep the corners of your eyes dry long enough for your liner to dry.

9/10, very good value. A great purse piece for it's tininess and built in applicator that isn't generous with application.

Best liner!

I bought this liner on a amazing sale & i'm totally in love with it. I found it was easy to handle, simple to apply & was long lasting! The price is pretty much average, but it's very effective & Im not disappointed. Lol

Not good..

I bought this based on price point. It's not worth your money. From the get-go it barely could draw a line. It gets caught on your skin, like it's sticky or something. I've used it twice and since tossed it. Wouldn't recommend this. Many other comparable products that do a better job.

Very nice... While it lasts

I get a beautiful winged eyeliner when using this product. However, I feel like it dried out so quickly by the time I used to it, I could no longer use it. I will be repurchasing though!

I've been using gel liner and a brush for years, but was able to quickly learn how to use this liquid eyeliner. The super fine tip is great for precision, compared to other liquid eyeliners that I've tried with a larger brush. At $8 a pop it's very affordable and easy to access (Superstore, Shoppers Drug Mart), however my last 2 eyeliners only last about a month each (based upon daily usage). I'm curious to see how the Kat Von D liquid liner stacks up, even though it's more expensive.

I absolutely love this joe fresh fine liquid eyeliner! It goes in great and even at the end if the day I'm really surprised of how easily it slides off my eyelids with my makeup remover! 9.5/10

This eyeliner lasts all day and is so easy to apply. I love this eyeliner and I find it the best I have tried. It gives you the right amount without any blobs . I have recommended this to many of my friends.

I absolutely love Joe Fresh liquid eyeliners!! I really like how smoothly it applies on. A lot of liquid liners break in the color because the texture is too thin but with this one it goes on evenly:) The price is right and I love this product:)

It smudged and was very hard to apply
I found it very hard to remove and it made my eye tear up I would not recommend this product and for the price wow

This is not a brand I tend to use very often, but I like to try new things from time to time, and this was on sale for a good price, so I decided, why not. Its an okay product, does what its supposed to, but I find that when it dries, it dries abit flaky or cracked. I like the precision of the tip though. Its hard to decide whether I like it or not, but if it goes on special again, I might buy it again, but not so sure its worth the price when its at full price.