Glittering star

I received the Jonteblue Glittering Star Eyeliner in my monthly BoxyCharm subscription box and I wasn't over thrilled with this eyeliner. I found that the pencil was harder than other eyeliners I have been using for many years now. I wasn't overly impressed with having to constantly go back & forth over and over the same spots to get a proper black liner look either. It did its job eventually, but I would have liked it better if it was a softer pencil & if I didn't have to line & reline to get it black enough for my liking.