I bought this at Sephora, because I wanted to try and alternative to the liquid eyeliner I usually use (smash box), and i found that the applicator was harder to control than the one I usually use, though the colour is amazing.

While I don't necessarily dislike this eyeliner, I do find that any drug store liner with a similar formula and brush is just as good as this one. It's easy to apply and a good black color, however I would hardly call it a stain, let alone a TATTOO. This stuff really doesn't have the staying power it claims to have. For the price, I'd rather go get a couple drug store liners.

Didn't like the product what made me purchase was the hype but honestly it wasn't worth it I didn't like the brush tip it wasn't for my eye shape and the color wasn't matte how I like mine I will stick to my elf one

I've heard so many great things about this eyeliner, but when I got it and tried it on it didn't live up to the hype. The ink wouldn't come out smoothly and when I finally got it to come out it looked streaky and not very pigmented. For the price of it you would expect it to be better than that; I find the clnique liquid eyeliner to be better quality and better price than this

Heard many great reviews about this product and was willing to spend the money to try it and hope for better results than I've had with other eyeliners but was very disappointed. This eyeliner was around $25 and did not meet my expectations at all. When applying the product (its a pen) the product would at first come out and then just stop mid way. Very disappointing since the liquid drys very fast and when you try to go over it, it messes the whole thing up.

Lasts great for a few weeks but dries out SO quick.
Also does not appear to be as black as other lines such as Stila or Marc Jacobs.
Price is good, but I ended up replacing it after 2-3 weeks so I'd rather pay an extra $10 and get one that will last me a good 2 months!

I received this liner as a gift, it's not a product I would typically buy for myself because I generally prefer gel eye liner. Overall it's pretty decent, one of the only things I struggle with some days when I use it is the pen running out of product before I can finish my wing, which results it me having to waste product by dabbing the pan on a tissue to get the liner flowing again. I'll be the first to admit this could be just from my lack of practice with this type of eyeliner but some days even with a lot of patience I can't seem to get a crisp line and this product can't easily be cleaned up with a Q-tip. It's drying time is also a great quality because it doesn't budge through out the day. In conclusion, I have other products I will tend to reach for if I want to do a thicker winged eyeliner, but it's great for when I want to apply falsies and want a thin layer of liner to fill the gap at my lash line. Also considering the price, I couldn't justify having this product in my collection after I use this initial one.

PROS: Very nice tip/brush for doing cat aye or any precise eye liner shape. very easy to use.
CONS: expensive and dry out fast after some uses.