My mom was buying her Lancome body lotion while we were shopping at Macy's and this caught my eye. Let me just start off by saying I wear liquid or gel eyeliner almost everyday. A dramatic cat eye is my signature look and I've been doing it since I was about 15. I was excited to try this out because I am very picky with my eyeliner and because I suffer from random bouts of watery eyes from allergens, staying power is a MUST. I heard very good things from multiple sources and even the girl at the counter gushed about it. So when the next day comes I excitedly swipe on my cat eye and I can't believe my eyes. The consistency was so thin and so very light. I checked the box to make sure I got black and I did. I had to build up to full black. So went on with my day and to my horror it was just smudging left and right. It did not last the day. I tried again for dinner that evening and the same result. I went and returned it the next day. I really did want to like it.