I got 2 of these eyeliners in dark blue and uptown brown.

I got these at my local annual lancome warehouse sale so the price was very affordable (only $8.00 each!) I see the normal retail price is around $24.00 but theres quite a bit in the pot.

The uptown brown is great it goes on smooth and even. It is soft like what you expect a gel liner to be. I am very pleased with this one. It does stay on the whole day but if you rub it does go away

However the blue is a different story - mine was hard and clumpy and goes on very uneven. I have to apply many coats to make it even look somewhat decent. Im not sure if this was just an old or defect one I got...