I have the black shade and I absolutely love this eyeliner for my tight line! It's one of the few eyeliners I've used that actually stays put in my tight line. It sometimes smudges a bit in the outer corner of my eye at the end of the day but that's after around 10-12 hours so doesn't really bother me.

This eyeliner claims to give the ease of a pencil with the intensity of a liquid liner. And let me tell you, it does what it claims. I have this in Noir Intense. It glides on so smoothly, is highly pigmented and doesn't budge. To have an eyeliner that basically looks like liquid liner but is easy to apply is awesome! I love it! I am definitely going to purchase more colours.