I found this makeup remover too greasy.
It feels like a film is left behind on the lashes.
It does remove waterproof mascara well,
but I only wear waterproof on special occasions.
I find this remover to heavy duty for everyday
use.

It works but it leaves you feeling yucky. I get these bottles as a sample all the time. I tried really hard to make it work. It just leaves an oily substance all over your face. It has a hard time removing my water proof eye liners.

This product gets amazing reviews and reader's choice awards in magazines everywhere, but I haven't found it that effective in removing waterproof mascara. I have to squeeze the cotton ball on my lashes to get the mascara off, which sometimes causes the lashes to fall out. For the price point, I would have expected it to remove mascara without any rubbing or excess pressure.