I have very oily skin and cant wear regular eyeliner's. If I do, the eyeliner is running down my face by 2:00 pm. However Lise Watier stays, I have no trouble with the eyeliner smudging or coming off. Great Product.

I have this in brown and in black. I love the fluidity and opaqueness of the liner and it is smuge proof. The felt tip in thin enough to create diverse eyeliner looks (thick to detail fine).

I was very excited to try this brown 'very long lasting, waterproof, no transfer' eyeliner but disappointed after paying $19 for it. It smudges and fades after just a couple of hours. It lasts a little longer when adding eye shadow before and after applying. But I would not buy this again.