This is a good eye liner. Does it's job as any waterproof eyeliner would. I liked that it did not smudge and stayed put. The application was easy with a pointy tip.

This is my holy grail of eyeliner. The foam tipped brush is relatively easy to use for someone with an unsteady hand like me and allows me to create thick or thin lines with precision. The amount of liquid to use can be controlled, and the bottle lasts for months. Once the liquid is set, it does not budge with rubbing or water at all. Dark Brown actually works well as an acceptable substitute to black. Clean up is easy with a good cleanser and water.

One thing - After a while, the plastic component that helps scrape off the liquid of the brush comes off and attaches itself onto the brush. It is an easy fix and not necessarily a nuisance for me because it is just that good.

Wow I love this eyeliner, I always have a hard time with lining my eyes especially with liquid eyeliner, however this eyeliner has a unique hard (yet gentle on the eye) edge point at the end which makes it super easy to learn how to apply liquid eyeliner. The quality is great, it stays on all day/time, it doesn't smudge at all, and if you make a mistake it can easily be removed with a makeup remover wipe. I would highly recommend this product to anyone starting off with liquid eyeliners, or anyone who is on the run and need a liquid eyeliner which can quickly applied without any mistake!