This product is very pigmented and applies very nice and smooth. Although it is a great product it does not stay all day in the waterline . If you have watery eyes it usually fades causing you to reapply. All in all I love this product and I still use it everyday and I would purchase it again. If you haven't already tried it go check it out the consistency is very creamy and smooth. Love it!

I love this product. It stays on for a few hours and doesn't bother my eyes.

I loved this eye-liner when I first bought it. My eyes are a bit sensitive but this product didn't irritate at all. It went on easily enough, lasted all day, and came off nicely at night. My only beef with this eye-liner is that the tip of the 'pencil' went flat for some reason (I don't apply undo pressure while using it, so I don't understand how that happened.) It bugs me because there is still a lot of liquid in the pencil, it's just that I can't get a fine line anymore. Like I said, my one and only issue with the pencil is how quickly it went flat, but other than that, it was great in every respect. I might even try another one...maybe I just got a lemon.

Love this eyeliner. It's easy to use and does a great job! I've been using it for years. I like the fact that it doesn't smudge, which is more important as you age and your lid starts to droop more.

I just reciently purchased the Loreal Paris Extra intense eyeliner. I am on a bugdet and was looking for a great eyeline for a great price. I purchased it hoping this product would work well for me and it did! I like the fact that it is not waterproof and stays on. By all means I am not the best makeup artist, far from it really and am super happy with my buy. I have very sensitive eyelids and had no problem with this eyeliner. Only one problem! I have now misplaced it :( and now needing to replace it, I will defiantly buy the same one.

This is the softest and most creamy pencil eye liner I have ever used from a drugstore. The formula is amazing and once set it will not more from where you put it. It has been compared to Macs coal liners and other high end liners and has come out to be equal if not better in quality and pigmentation. It is a remarkable product, perfect for those smokey eyed looks that require such a liner, and with a reasonable price, how can it be beat?

I have never liked pencil eyeliner, I always use liquid, so when i saw this on the shelf last week, I picked one up to try it out as it looked very interesting! And i wasn't disappointed! It goes on so smooth and creamy, but not like a regular pencil, it has the same effect as the liquid eyeliner! I was shocked! On the downfall, it does need to be sharpened, which isn't a huge deal, however that is a big difference from liquid. Also it says that it's infallible for 16 hours, obviously we all know that won't happen.. And last but not least it does NOT smudge like a regular eyeliner! ( when you are taking it off it does give you a bit of raccoon eyes). All in all: I like!

Usually I buy cheap, crappy eyeliners (like NYC or Wet N' Wild), so for once I decided to get a decent one. I was drawn to this particular eyeliner for a few reasons: first of all, very dark black (other choices were brown and dark grey). Second, the softness of a liquid liner with the precision of a pencil (meaning a bolder line). And lastly, the promise of "lasts up to 16 hours). I don't expect it to last that long, but if it lasts longer than one of those 99-cent Wet N' Wild pencils, it's got my attention.

Was not impressed with the price, but I'm cheap and I'm sure it will be worth it in the long run. And honestly, I'm quite pleased with it. It can get a little messy if used on the lower lids and may require a touch-up in the corners of the eyes now and then. Overall, though, it stays put relatively well for a cream liner. I fell asleep with it on and when I woke up, it wasn't smudged. Mine did not come with the blending tip on the other end, but I don't usually blend my eyeliner anyway - I like a thick, bold and solid line.

So if you're looking for a long-lasting and bold black eyeliner, this is a really nice one if you don't feel like going to Sephora and giving them your first born for an eyeliner. You can most likely get this at any CVS or Wal-Mart.

I really like this eyeliner- it's smooth and smudge-able and lives up to the title "liquid pencil eyeliner"- which at first, I didn't get but it really is very smooth- almost like a liquid liner.

I love the fact that it comes with a rubber tip on the other end so you can smudge your makeup to create a smokey eye. It's a very pigmented and intense colour and keeps for an entire day. It doesn't really dry like other liners though making it very easy to get all over your face and hands.