Love it would buy again

I use this black eye liner on a daily basis. It's smudge proof and makes my eyes pop. I love how smooth it goes on and it's very easy to take off too.

Long Lasting and Easy to apply

I managed to score this eyeliner for $2 on clearance, and I'm so glad to have discovered it! I've been using pencil eyeliner for many years, as my previous brief forays into liquid and gel eyeliner didn't go so well (yet I could line my eyes with a pencil in the dark!), so at the discounted price I thought I'd give this style of eyeliner a try.
It goes on smooth, precise, bold and stays put for all day wear.
My only cons are the regular price, in comparison to a pencil liner, it's a little higher, but not outrageous considering the performance - and that I find the tip can dry out rather quickly, so I cap and "reload" during application to avoid this being an issue.

I agree that not all of L'oreal product are great including the infallible collection!
But this product definitely do the work!
It's easy to use even though you are not really great at doing eye make up. I was able to do my eyeliner in 1 glide, and yes thats how amazing it was.

I'm southeast asian and i tend to go for super dark black eyeliner to help enhance the size of my eyes. And it is what it is when they called it black velvet, you get it for thin to thick lines and ultimate bold eye look