Great eyeliner!

This eyeliner works very well! It doesn't tug on your waterline, and it's smudgeable because it's extremely creamy. It can smudge and run a little if you are sweating, or somewhere hot and humid. But in normal conditions, it does fine.

This is a rather new product from L'oreal and I got mine in the highlighter version/shade, which is a shimmery rose-gold/champagne color. The pencil itself is really nice - it's creamy and smooth and doesn't tug at your eye. It's the color that disappoints me. On the skin, like around the inner eye corner and along the lashline, it's beautiful, but in the waterline, it's not even noticeable. It doesn't look like there's any liner there at all, and I don't notice any "brightening" effect. While I don't like this in the waterline, it does look really pretty around the inner corner of the eye. I don't think it's worth the money for just this purpose though. There are much better liners out there. Disappointed.