Mixed feelings

I have mixed feelings about this eyeliner. It's very pigmented and goes on very dark like it promises which I love. It also stays on well, it doesn't smear and will often last the whole day without needing touch-ups. I'm not so sure about the brush. I find it's very easy to do bold lines with it, but thin ones are much more difficult, and getting the corners or a sharp tail to a cateye is a little hard with this one as well.

For a drugstore liquid eye-liner, it delivers precision, intensity and lasting power.
It is easy to apply and handle.
I don't use liquid eyeliner everyday and yet, it doesn't dry up.
L'Oreal should consider creating different colors for this product.

I really like this eyeliner, I have it in Black :)
I find the brush tip applicator easy to use, and making a nice clean line is simple.
The eyeliner lasts several hours and won't smudge or fade unless the eye is rubbed.
Unlike other liquid eyeliners from the drugstore you get plenty of product.
It's not amazing by any means, and I'd like to use an eyeliner that didn't fade after time.

I have the typical Asian eyes...I don't leave my house without having eyeliner on haha. I tried a lot of eyeliners... the pencils, the gels... you name it. But this liquid liner was very easy for me. Esp if your not a talented makeup artist the felt tip helps it glide on smoothly...because if not done right... liquid liners are a complete mess! & it also lasted me a whole night of dancing at the clubs. =]

Its got a good pen size, and if you lay it flat on your lid and pull straight...then its ok if you dont have steady hands. it doesnt last all day and not too dramatic, but good for work

Out of all the liquid eyeliners I've used, this is my favorite. It goes on very smoothly, and the felt tip is fairly easy to control.
With all eyeliners (pencil and liquid), I have trouble getting it to go on in a straight line. I've got shakey hands. This one is the easiest for me to use. I can control how thick or thin I want the line to be pretty well, and if I screw up, it comes off really easily.
The color is nice (I use carbon black), and it doesn't smudge or run at all during the day. If I put it on in the mornings, it's still great by night.
The tip is really thin, and if you press a little harder you can get a thicker line, so it's great for dramatic (or undramatic, depending on your taste) eyes.