I went sent on a mission to find the best eyeliner for my sister that is easy to use and long lasting, and i thought i had found a winner when i came across this L'oreal product cause this is what it stated on the packaging.
but it was completely false! This is one of L'oreal's worst product yet! :(
- the pen is long and hard to hold, i can't get too close to the mirror or the pen will tap into the mirror
- the liquid is runny and watery, and takes a long time to dry so you cannot blink during the drying process or it will smudge against your lids
- i chose the black eyeliner, but the result is more a grey color, not impressive!
- after the liquid dries, it still smudges easily and flakes too

overall: highly highly disappointed!! :(
stay away from it if you can!

The earth brown barely shows up at all and the liner is difficult to apply.

i loveee this eyeliner...ive used other ones such as the popular maybelline liner and it always smudges...but this one doesnt...its good for the price and it comes off easily wen u just wipe ur eyes with a wet towel...ur already done removing it cause i hate liners that take forveer to come off.

I absolutely love this liner. I wasn't very good with liquid liner and I always used to mess up and have to do my makeup all over again so I decided to get rid of the "flimsy" brush liners and go for the felt tip. I had tried a couple other felt tip liners before this one, but this is the only one that I use as of now. It gives you very good control, it's easy to make thick or thin lines, and I haven't noticed any colour fading as some other girls have, and the handle is very easy to grip and is great for precision lining. This liquid liner works best for me and I don't see myself buying anything else.

I recommend it highly!