The liquid liner is wayyyy better, this felt tip liner is harder to apply, and it doesn't last as long. For the same price, get the liquid liner!

It's not stiff or flimsy. Not to wet, so no smudging or smears. Good colour and long lasting.

I tried the product after a beauty guru recommended it. It did not have enough pigmentation right at the start and it took a lot of effort to get the product out and actually apply. Bad experience overall.

Was a little overpriced for drugstore makeup. It worked well and lasted for most of the day, but I felt that it was not dark enough.

This liner makes it so easy to get a precise smooth line! With its fluid, carbon black formula it is so easy to draw on a smooth line, or even add a wing. The brush tip also contributes to the ease of the product, not too stiff or flimsy. Does not smudge or budge throughout the day either.

Not one of my favourite liquid eyeliners, but gets the job done. The felt tip brush makes application very easy, but the eyeliner itself appears shiny when it is applied and easily wipes away if you touch it.

Very easy to control for a percise line. Great for beginners as well. Only downfall is that it seems to get in the corners of my eyes through out the day.

I am not much of a "liquid" eye liner wearer, but I did buy this for my daughters recital and found it easier to put on her than a pencil style. I did use this on a few occasions and found it does take some getting used to. I like it because it gives a bit more defined line and it is either thick or thin. It dries fairly quickly.

This is the first felt tip eyeliner that I have found that lasts all day, does not smudge, and also has a long shelf life. I bought the covergirl on previously and it was dry within a month or 2.
This is super black, easy to use, and you can make a thin or thick line.

I have been using this for over 5 years. Great lines it produces, and very opaque.