Best liquid liner EVER!

I've tried them all, and I can honestly say that as far as liquid liners go, this is the BEST one out there. I've been using it for 10 years (at least!) and I never go anywhere without one in my purse (I wear it every day). Love the precision and ease of application, and I regularly get asked what eye liner I use, even by strangers. I truly swear by this FELT TIP (the most important feature) liner. It also stays put, but comes off easily with any decent eyemakeup remover. I use it daily with mascara, and always use it with a smoky, sexy eye - you can layer it either above or below eyeshadow and it still goes on smooth and perfect.

This make a novice makeup wearer look like a pro!

When I was freelancing as a Makeup Artist, I'd often get asked how to recreate my dramatic Cat-Eye look. One thing I always told my clients is that fabulous products aren't always accompanied by high prices. The eye liner is a prime example. The felt tip is great for creating precise line and wand can be used like a marker. The colour is insanely black and perfect for a gorgeous defined look.

I absolutely love this eyeliner!

This liner is great for so many reasons. The formula lasts all day long without smudging (even into the next day if I sleep with it on :-P) The felt-tip makes this eyeliner so easy to apply and makes it simple to create different looks with wide/thin lines, curvy/straight lines, etc. i like to keep my eyeliner thin in the middle, and then a bit thicker on the outer edges, but I've tried several different looks and always have had success.

I seriously love everything about this eyeliner and have gotten many family members and friends hooked on it too.

I always have loved making my eyes pop out by using liquid liner. After having used several different brands of liquid liner, I had settled on this one quite some time ago.

The felt tip definitely makes the liquid liner easy to apply; once you get used to the way the tip moves along your lid line, application and manoeuvring the tip becomes quite easy.

The liquid liner definitely has staying power, however, I often find that my liner seems a bit lighter and worn at the end of the day than at the start – nothing too drastic or concerning though. I love that this specific liner never irritates my eyes; many other liners make my eyes water all day, which always result in me smudging the line I created. This liner has proven to be the best for me in terms of being non-irritating.

I do find when I place this liner on extremely shimmery eye shadow, it doesn't really stand out, but for regular day wear, I highly recommend this product! I use this liner everyday and the little tube lasts for ages – definitely worth the cost, which in comparison to other liquid liners, is highly reasonable and affordable.

It is the best eyeliner for everyone. Since it has a felt tip, it makes applying the liner effortless. It is so easy to make your liner as thick or as thin as you like. It is definitely worth every penny.

This eyeliner is AMAZING. I have tried many different brands of liquid liner including high-end ones, yet I keep coming back to this one.

Price 5/5: Since it's a drugstore product, the price really can't be beat. It's like getting a high-end product for a drugstore price.

Quality 5/5: I use this product every day and I've never experienced any irritation. The carbon black formula is more intense than the previous black colour that l'oreal was selling, and lasts all day without requiring touch ups.

Effectiveness 4.5/5: This liner is perfect for a beginner to use. Since the tip is felt rather than a brush, it's stiffer and more cohesive. The tip is more comparable to using a marker rather than a brush. It 's able to create precise lines in varying thickness, depending on the user's preference. The only reason why I did not give it 5/5 is because it's not waterproof. If you were to tear excessively, or if water somehow gets splashed onto your eye, you may have to re-apply since the product will become faint.

Overall fantastic. I have lots of back-ups of this product in my drawer just in case l'oreal decides to discontinue it.

i loveee this eyeliner...ive used other ones such as the popular maybelline liner and it always smudges...but this one doesnt...its good for the price and it comes off easily wen u just wipe ur eyes with a wet towel...ur already done removing it cause i hate liners that take forveer to come off.

I absolutely love this liner. I wasn't very good with liquid liner and I always used to mess up and have to do my makeup all over again so I decided to get rid of the "flimsy" brush liners and go for the felt tip. I had tried a couple other felt tip liners before this one, but this is the only one that I use as of now. It gives you very good control, it's easy to make thick or thin lines, and I haven't noticed any colour fading as some other girls have, and the handle is very easy to grip and is great for precision lining. This liquid liner works best for me and I don't see myself buying anything else.

I recommend it highly!