This product is not very good quality , however it does the trick and allows you to make smooth lines while doing winged eyeliner. I will always prefer the Mac liquid eyeliner for the quality but this is a close one for a much better price. I would recommend this to someone who may not be able to afford very high end makeup (:

I find the felt tip hard to control and I don't find the liner itself to be dark or matte enough for my needs.

The liquid liner is wayyyy better, this felt tip liner is harder to apply, and it doesn't last as long. For the same price, get the liquid liner!

Not one of my favourite liquid eyeliners, but gets the job done. The felt tip brush makes application very easy, but the eyeliner itself appears shiny when it is applied and easily wipes away if you touch it.

This eyeliner definitely does the job! I was using a different eyeliner upon receiving it so I sort scoffed at this when it was given to me. However one day when I wasn't able to find my other trusty eyeliner, this of course was my back up and it wasn't a total fail! The great thing about this is the felt tip. You can go as thin or as thick as you want. The formula is definitely on the thinner side, so you may have to do a few extra strokes so you don't see your skin complexion through the eyeliner, which is my pet peeve with this product. It also rubs off easily. It's not the best eyeliner I've ever tried and it's not worst, it just isn't anything special for my beauty needs.