This was a quick purchase because I needed a refill on my lip liner. L'Oreal products are usually high in quality, and the price you pay is worth it. Definitely not in this case. I was so upset when the color of a LIP LINER was clumpy. They staying power was nil, and very upsetting. Also, the color that was on the cap and the little palette at the store was a different shade after I put it on. I would not buy this product again.