Great mascara

This is one of the best mascaras I have ever used. It makes my lashes long and it does not smudge throughout the whole day. The wand is also extremely easy to use

Definite Favorite

It makes your eyelashes grand and luxurious. The smooth consistency makes it easy to apply. and the feathered brush applies more volume than ever. It does last 24 hours and sometimes even more. Not waterproof but doesn't give in easily. A girls true best friend.

When I first got this mascara, I found it to be really clumpy. However, I have found that this is a really good mascara to be used on top of other mascaras after separating and defining the lashes. This is the most volumizing mascara I have encountered, and it really gives extra volume to the lashes. This is also very black, and lasts and really long time.

When I first got this mascara, I found it to be really clumpy. However, I have found that this is a really good mascara to be used on top of other mascaras after separating and defining the lashes. This is the most volumizing mascara I have encountered, and it really gives extra volume to the lashes. This is also very black, and lasts and really long time.

Trying this mascara was quite a big step for me since normally I don't use any mascara other than CoverGirl, and especially LashBlast. But I kind of wanted to try something new and I've always heard good things about L'Oreal. I totally love this one! I have such thin, sparse lashes. When I was buying, the lady at Shoppers Drug Mart told me this is her fave since she has no lashes as well. I loved that it built up volume for me and some length - but nothing crazy. Without eyeliner, I think this is completely suitable for day wear. It gives like a "dramatic day" look if that makes sense! I've worn it to school during the day then added a smidge of eyeliner on my top lid for going out that night - totally works! I don't think it quite replaces LashBlast for me but it is a close second!

I think this is a great and cheaper alternative to Diorshow mascara. It's a bit pricier than other L'oreal mascaras but I thought it was completely worth it. I haven't experienced any problems with clumping, and got fantastic volume and definition.

Did not like this product at all.. I actually found through the day that my eye's were really itchy to the point I had to take this off during the day, add eye drops and apply a different brand.. I than tried again a few days later and had the same problem..first time I ever had a mascara both me. Yes it was brand new never opened or used..

This really dries up on your lashes and makes them really hard and eventually clump together. I am no longer a fan of mascara's that say they have a collagen formula, as I've experienced the hardening lashes with another collagen formula mascara.

Yeah this is terrible. The brush looks good but the formula is beyond horrible. By the time I try to apply a second coat the mascara dries up into this hard ... thing, on my lashes, making them stiff and making it impossible for me to build up volume or length. The worst part is taking it off. I use oil to remove my make up, a very effective and gentle method to remove even the most stubborn water proof product... well not this guy! I need to soak my lashes, and scrub and soak and scrub. It literarlly hurts removing this!
Overall a big fail. It doesnt perform, it doesnt look good, it doesnt feel good and its almmost impossible to take it off.

I recently ran out of my Loreal Voluminous mascara and was in the make up isle at walmart i decided to try the extra volume collagen mascara in blackest black and of course waterproof.

This mascara claims to "...enhance the thickness of your lashes for up to 12X more impact without the clumps...."

That did not prove itself at all. This is an aweful mascara. That clumps and flakes more than any I have ever tried before. This by far is the worst.

After applying one coat I noticed no change. Then with the second coat there was extreme clumping and it did not go on easily. It added no volume and my lashes just seemed to stick together. I would definately not recommend this mascara.

I think I will stick to my Loreal Voluminous mascara. That is the best ever and it has never proved me wrong. :)