I love this black liquid eyeliner!! It has a fine, thin tip which makes it very easy to apply the liner to the lid and the colour is dark and rich. If you make a mistake, it is easy to fix and it's very convenient to use when you are in a hurry. I usually use this one on the days I'm time-limited and the L'oreal gel eyeliner on days I have more time.

Amazing eyeliner. Very easy to use and the colour payoff is amazing. Doesn't smudge throughout the day and stays put for a good time.
I'd say it's a bit hard to remove with a simple makeup remover but it might be that i'm too soft with my eyes because I'm afraid to cause wrinkles haha.

I'd say it's not beginner friendly.

Loveit love it. Such ease to apply and last all day no smudging

I love this product. Its the best liquid eyeliner ive used. It glides nicely, lasts all day, and doesnt smudge.

This product goes on well, comparable to Marc Jacobs eyeliner pen. I find the brush extremely easy to use and the black colour bold.

This liquid eye liner is incredible. I have tried many higher end liquid liners and this one is by far the best. It goes on your eye lid so smoothly and doesn't come off throughout the day. I will buy this eye liner forever!!

i like how slim the eyeliner is, but the tip of it is a bit soft for me. and when i draw a wing, when i am not really really careful, it will be easily erased in the middle of the day/night. but nevertheless, it is easy to use and i love how dark its shade is.

It's got great pigment and lasts all day long looking great

I love the packaging, I love how slim and thin the pen is. It makes for a great application and the tip is so fine and makes it easy to make thin or thick lines. The formula is very dark black which I love, although also a bit dry and not as smooth as the past eyeliners ive used. Also my skin is not oily at all, mainly dry but throughout the day the eyeliner smudges in my creases which hardly occurs with other eyeliners.

I have used all kinds of eyeliner from pencil, to liquid, to gel and i have never tried this eyeliner, its like a liquid pen for eyeliner and it is amazing. It is great for small details and wing eyeliner. I use it for my everyday eyeliner routine, it is easy to make really thin lines as well as thicker lines. It stays on and doesn't run. I am a klutz and have never poked myself in the eye with this, the eyeliner is super easy to control and it is quick to use, it also removes easily if you do make a mistake.