I bought this mascara because I heard a few good reviews about it, and I love anything that will make my lashes look as maximized as possible. I bought the waterproof version, and it was the worst thing ever. First of all within an hour of wearing the mascara the fibers flaked off into my eyes resulting in them looking red and watery, and itching like crazy. When I went to remove it with make-up remover it would not come off! I had to scrub my lashes to death to get the mascara off and it wasn't fun trying to get all the fibers out of my eyes. I was really sad it didn't work for me, because I usually love L'oreal mascaras.