Good for Halloween

The chunkiness of this eyeliner makes it almost impossible to use as a daily product unless you’re going for that goth look! Also, the pigment isn’t great, which means to get it to black, instead of just grey, you have to go over your line a few times!

This was recommended to me by a makeup artist. She said it would not move on your waterline but i find it's absolutely not true. It's very greasy so it will run off your eyelid as well. When I apply it, I can see it lose its opacity even before I leave the house to go to work. I'm not sure how much I paid for this but it was certainly more than it's worth. Would not recommend.

This is also a very soft crayon type eyeliner. I do like the black or the blue. I alternate on days as to which color to use. It stays on all day without smudging.

such a nice dark black eyeliner that stays on your waterline all day long. It is so easy to you and doesn't make a mess in the waterline during application and throughout the day it doesn't run through the sides of your eyes. well worth it

LOVE LOVE LOVE! I have dark brown eyes and I got this eyeliner in black. It's a very dark shade and is great to use waterlines for added volume of your lashes. I haven't tried it yet for eyeliner on my top lid but I'm sure that it would look fab. This stick is a bit chubby so you do have to be a little careful.

This eyeliner is thick and looks similar to a jumbo pencil from NYX but it doesn't work like one at all. I was expecting a very smudge-able pencil, but this one is much more similar to a regular eyeliner. I like that it comes with it's own sharpener and so you can sharpen it enough to create a thin line but used on it's side you can create a thicker one.

It's a very intense and pigmented colour. It stays on pretty long and doesn't really move around like a cheaper eyeliner might. I'm not sure if it worth almost $9 US but it's a good product and as a huge fan of black liner, I love that this one creates a really deep and striking look.

I received this product to review from L'Oreal Paris.