In two words very good, it's perfect i liée This eyeliner pencil

I really truly love this eyeliner. I wear it on my waterline and it goes on super smooth. I find the upper waterline stays on all day long and totally make my eyes pop. The lower waterlines stays on most of the day but definately not as long as when I wear it on the upper lines. I use ebony and love everything there is to it, from the price to the wear. Perfetion.