I have oily skin and all liquid, gel, and pencil liners never survive on my eyelids. Unfortunately this one is one of the ones that won't last on my eyelids unless I use a base like Urban Decay primer portion, but when I do use a base on my eyes, the MAC blacktrack fluidline is my favorite thing to use to do the winged eyeliner look. It does not dry too fast and applies really smooth and has a really good color pay off. I wish the formula was made to last without a primer or base underneath though.

I was sick of my eyeliners fading and wearing off during the day. I was little worried at first about applying it. But in the beginning I would draw my line with a eyeliner pencil first (basically a trace line) then go over it with a fluidline and a small angled brush but now i'm so comfortable with it now I can do without the trace line. It stays in place, looks sharp and doesn't fade. Worth every penny!

For the longest time I avoided buying one of these... I figured it was the same as all the other gel liners I had used in the past from the drugstore & that it wasn't worth the price tag... WRONG! I bought one of the most recent ones from the Shop/Cook collection in Wholesome. I find that black is a tad too harsh on me for everyday and figured that the dark chocolate colour of this would be a happy medium between black & brown. It is perfection. It glides on smoothly, never fades, flakes or smears and lasts all day until I remove it. I have since purchased Waveline as well & will not hesitate to buy another if they release new colours! It is worth the hype & the price tag - a definite repurchase!

I used to use pencil eyeliner and when I picked up this gel eyeliner, I don't want to go back to pencil eyeliner anymore. Gel eyeliner is easy to apply and you can direct how thick or thin or the shape of how you want it to look. It's also very smooth to apply and blends well onto the skin.

It was hard to remove pencil eyeliner completely with makeup remover. With this gel, it was removed very easily without constant rubbing.

I love this product!!! I use is daily and i rather this then a pencil anyway!!! This doesn't leek or smug easy and with a baby its a life saver! I even got my mom to start using this! Lol :) This might be a touch expensive but its worth every dime and last a long time! 

It's rather brilliant. I marked it as amazing, because there's no other eyeliner like it really, unless there's a gel eyeliner from another company. Way better than liquid 'cause it won't automatically come off if the eye gets wet, like liquid has more of a chance of doing. Easier to apply than liquid. Really amazingly decent product.

I love this product. i use the black fluidline everyday. I put in on every morning and it last all day. The price is a little high in price but it is still a great product to use.

Very smooth going on and perfect lines all the time

I really wanted to love this, but it just didn't stay put. After a few hours, the liner just disappeared..it didn't even smudge under my eyes, weird.

Love! I use this on myself as well as in my kit. Its so smooth and creamy when it goes on but stays right in place.No smudging and it lasts for ever!! A must have for the cat eye look!!!