overpriced for the name.

i literally live for liquid eyeliner, it's my best friend. every.single.day.
i was told about this product a few years ago and thought "hey, absolutely i'll try it"
we already know MAC is expensive so i knew that walking into the store. i bought it, went home and tried it.
god i was so disappointed. the product sucks! it's not at all dark (how i like my makeup) and i had to shake the bottle for liquid to come onto the stick. this product isn't worth the price.

Not black enough and hard to use

You have to shake the bottle to get the color to be black. Or else you'll get a runny grey consistency. the brush is good for laying the basic color in between the lashes to get a thick liner look. But not ideal for the thin eyeliner look. If you want a thin line with this, the brush is quiet bulky for the look so it will take longer to do your thin eyeliner. I'm don't get oily but I do notice the line smudge a bit at the end of the day. Also it is terribly difficult to remove it after, i use 2 mac makeup wipes. not a good sign