I have the brown version of this mascara, and I find that it really isn't worth buying.
The brush is way to thick, so when applying, it feels as though the whole brush will end up in my eye. Plus!, it is very clumpy when removing from the tube and applying, and the final result isn't as great as you think it should be.
My bad review of it could be because it is the brown version, but I wouldn't risk buying it again just to try it out.

I hate this product! all this time I 'loved' it because it was from MAC and supposed to be amazing quality. I've been wearing it for months and had terrible smudges all the time! today I came home with ridiculous coon eyes for the last time. I'd rather use drugstore mascara than this again.
BTW my lids don't get really oily and I was wearing a primer as well. AND i only coated the lashes midway so it wouldn't transfer that much!
very disappointed.