I will not go back to my regular eyeliners after I have tried this one from Marc Jacobs. I've used it plenty of times to say that I've worn it all day and no smears. What else do I want from an eyeliner.

Love this eyeliner by Marc Jacobs! I purchased this product from Sephora for $31 in the satin finish colour Blacquer. The staying power of this product is beyond amazing! It literally looks exactly the same hours later as it did when you first put it on. I've used many eyeliner products in the past that smudge and/or fade really quickly so I was really impressed with how well this product holds up.

The colour is lush and rich and the sensational gel formula means it goes on so smoothly and easily. I've even noticed that when I rim my lower lashes with this product, I can very carefully smooth this over my lower lashes and it works as a picture perfect, long-lasting mascara that highlights each lash so well!

The crayon comes with a built in sharpener in the base. This product is well worth the money and the formula they have come up with is a beauty winner!

I LOVE this eyeliner! I first tried it as the b-day sample from Sephora and I liked it so much that I've bought the full size. I fell in love with gel liners years ago and normally use MAC Fluidline or Bobbi Brown, but the pot and brush are a bit cumbersome for travel. This combines the awesome application and waterproof benefits of those in the convenience of a pencil. It really does not budge - I wear this after working out and it's still perfectly on. Worth every penny. Great colour selection too!

I got a mini version of this eyeliner as a Sephora birthday gift and fell absolutely in LOVE with it. The liner has a wonderful creamy feel and goes on so smoothly. I have consistently watery eyes and I found this stays on very well once applied. The full-size version has a special tiny sharpener hidden in the end, which is the perfect size for sharpening without breaking the tip off and making a mess. The liner does sharp lines very well, and is also great for smudging.

The price of the liner is a bit high(at over $30), but my mini liner lasted me over 3 months (had to throw it out because it didn't come with a sharpener and was too small to fit in my full-sized sharpener) and I've had the full-sized one for 4 months already and not even half used. If you're going for top quality (and can afford to pay for the name on the product), I highly recommend this liner and the price is totally worth the result

Got this Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon as a Sephora Birthday Gift. I am now obsessed and will likely stick to buying only this Eye Liner.

I don't typically wear makeup unless I'm going out or downtown to dance my blues away. This definitely passes the sweaty dance moves test. No smudging while dancing my heart out. I've even worn it to bed after a night out when I was too lazy to wash it off and no raccoon eyes in the morning! I have even gotten up and gone to work the next day with it and it still looks freshly applied.

Definitely no re-application needed for heavy dancing nights. You will need makeup remover to remove it, but it's not the type that you have stuck to your face for weeks even after trying to remove with makeup remover.

On the pricier side but totally worth it!

I'm a Marc Jacobs everything fanatic so my opinion might very biased. I have received this eyeliner as part of the birthday gift program from Sephora.

First, I like the eyeliner, but it's not my favorite. It goes on very precise and smooth, color is very pigmented. The part that I don't like is that, it does smudged a little bit compare to the other eyeliner's I have.

It does goes very smooth like the gel liner from M.A.C (which used to be my go to). This liner is easy to use, and the full size version has a sharpener at the end of the pencil which I think is very neat and convenient. The deluxe sample I received as a birthday gift is a twist on at the end, which is neat because you don't need to sharpen it.

Overall it's a good eyeliner after you let it set, it lasts for a long time. Just try not to touch it before then because it will smudge a little bit.

I received a deluxe sample of this in my Sephora Birthday Gift.

I've tried many different pencil eyeliners over the years, but none of them have felt like this. This glides on impossibly smoothly, just like a potted gel eyeliner. The pigmentation is absolutely insane to the point where you barely even need to touch your skin to get full colour. You can get an easy and perfect application in one sweep, without having to tug at your eyelids or go over with multiple layers.

Once this sets down, it stays in place all day. It won't smudge or budge. I've worn this outside when it was raining enough to get my face wet, and it didn't move. I've worn it during a massage therapy session, with my face smushed into a towel, and it didn't move. The quality is exceptional.

The only downside is the price. A full size is quite expensive, and I'm not sure if I'm willing to part with more than $30 for a single pencil. But this really is a great product.

I love this eyeliner it goes on smooth. Its not messy and you can easily smudge it for a smokey look. I have the black and it looks great with all the pinks and purples i wear.

The best eye liner to use on your water line! Stays put all day, without smudging or fading. It glides on, so smooth and easily. A bit pricey though, but lasts.

This is an awesome product! A tad pricey (31 cad at sephora) but sooooo worth the price! I have never ever found an eyeliner that stays this well in place, and believe me, I've tried a lot. Somehow eyeliner never stays where it's supposed to with me, but this one does. Easy to apply, lovely. Definitely recommend!