I really loved Marcelle product :) all marcelle product never desappointed me !!

it's not expensive and good hypolaargen

The eyeliner went on smoothly and allowed you to achieve a pretty straight line effectively. It did not smudge and looked good for the whole day.

love the liner itself hate the faulty retractable that doesn't work well!

I got this in Azure for free from the brand. I LOVE the colour. It's a rich denim blue that I think is very flattering with blue eyes without looking 80s inspired. It's a twist up and the liner is smooth to apply. It comes with a smudger at the end, which is a nice feature. I do find it can travel a bit by the end of the day. Not tragically so, but something that prevents me from giving this the full five stars. I adore the colour and will continue to use it.