I bought this because it was recommended by the domestic associate at my local shoppers drug mart because I have sensitive eyes and the tend to be watery but I did not like it this eyeliner at all because it's hard to put on and it does not stay on ! I have to re apply a few times a day, not waterproof. I was pretty disappointed

Though this product is waterproof, it does fade slightly by the end of the day. A simple touch up is all that's needed to get through the evening.

I'd rather have a bit of fading than big runny lines on my lids and side of eyes.

I've been using it for years and won't change. There are many "waterproof" brands available at twice the price that don't work any better than Marcelle.

I am allergic to around everything so it is nice to have a product I could use!

Terrible! It barely goes on. I liked it at first because it was a lighter black and it didn't create a dramatic look. However, now that I am half way through the product, I would recommend others at cheaper prices and better qualities. I do find that this product is not harmful to your eye areas and can even be used to line your tight line! That is probably the only positive. I will use it up probably.

I love this eyeliner. It goes on super smooth, super easy and there is no need to press hard at all. It comes in many diffrent colors and its hypo-allergenic. Its waterproof, but is not too hard to get off with your regular facial cleanser. It hasen't seemed to smudge alot, well atleast on me. Overall its a great eyeliner and I would reccomend it.