I don't use black eye liner a lot but when I do this is the one I love.....it has the correct glide so that your not pulling your eyes and it stays put all day!

Made eyes very black.... use lightly if you arent fond of being v dark around the eyes! Still liked it however... very grungy and gothic looking but very nice

I got this eye liner for my daughter last year. My daughter like make up. She doesn't really like alot on. So I got this eye liner to see if would like it. She told me that this eye liner was easy to put on. She like the colour and looked really nice with rest of her make up.I asked her if she would buy it? She said yes I would.

Crisp, no unintentional smudging... stayed in place all night.

At $18 it is literally a RIPOFF of eyestudio maybelline gel eyeliner which is around $5-$7 at Walmart!
Why pay more for a BRAND NAME???
Plus the Maybelline one comes with a much better brush applicator.