As far as wooden pencil lip liners go, this one is a fail in my opinion. The color (Primrose) is absolutely perfect, its just slightly lighter and pinker than my natural lip color. However, that's as far as the good qualities go with this product. The formula is dryer than the desert, and it settles into every line on and around my lips. At first I tried to fill in my entire lip area with this pencil, and that is what is pictured in the photos I added. This lip liner would be best if kept to just the outline of the lips, but even then, there are far better liners out there than this one. The staying power is little to none, it just cracks up and separates on my lips. I would pass on this one, ladies and gentlemen!