So I got this product for free to test out. I am by no means great at putting on eyeliner, it fact my skills are kinda below average so I was excited when I saw that this eyeliner claims to make application easier.Unfortunately I found that the paddle applicator makes it harder for me to use because it was kind of stiff and I found that it sort of skipped over some parts where creases where, so the line wasn't really as clean and sharp as I would've preferred. The formula however was really really nice, it was completely jet black and it lasted all day long. Overall I would recommend this to someone else who had more eyeliner skills than I.