Great product, would but again.

Good for its price. Last pretty well and doesn’t smudge much compared to other brands. Definitely not waterproof but works if set with a setting spray.

Okay

Wasn’t the best liner ever but it definitely did it’s job. Wore off quite quickly despite the fact that this is maybelline and I had high hopes after their “super stay” collection

Softer liner goes on smooth

What I like most about this liner is that it is soft so goes on easily and smoothly. I can’t stand hard liners and it looks so uneven. The dark colour looks great as well.