I have this product in the shade Amethyst Smokes. It isn't something I reach for often, but when I do, I do like it. It's very so-so and average if used on its own, but with a base the colors show up better. The colors are beautiful and shimmer, and if you like purple shades, I would recommend this quad in Amethyst Smokes.

I have some of the other Maybelline eye shadows and I love them so when I saw the expertwear shadows I was really happy. I needed a dark brown eye shadow in my collection and I really liked the look of the Nutmeg shadow. It is a beautiful dark brown matte color and you get a lot of product for the price.
That's about where the happiness ended. The color was very pigmented, which is good, but it had a lot of fallout. The shadow is really chalky and doesn't apply very well. It is not very smooth/creamy.
I do not know how the other colors are, but I am not very happy with Nutmeg. It might work better for someone else, or it just happened to be that particular shadow that I got, but overall it's an okay eye shadow.