I have this in Barely Beige and it is terrible. It is very hard, applies on streaky and smudges! Nothing much I can do with this except put a touch of it on the inner eye. Very disappointing.

I have a few of the brighter colours. They are great for using as a base.

I have six of these shades and I LOVE THEM. They stay on really well (actually they are hard to get off!), they dont crease and it is super pigmented. Pretty much what you see is what it is like on your eyes.

I tried a couple of these as they were a gift from someone. I wasn't that thrilled with them as she was. They do come in lots of pretty colors.

So it's been a while since I have these in 3 colors and I have to say the color payoff is amazing!
I have Pomegranate Punk, Bad to the Bronze and the Leather edition in Drama Black.
The first two from the original line are amazing but still I'd recommend a primer if you have oily lids and specially if you're planning to use them alone without any eyeshadow on top of the cream gel eyeshadow.
The Leather edition in Drama Black is a bit messy to apply and I feel like it doesn't set like the other two. The formula feels a bit dryer than the other ones and it doesn't glide smooth onto your lids like you'd expect cream gel to do.
I tried using the black one as a gel liner and I must say I works really good although sometimes I find myself using a damp brush to make it glide much more easily or even applying a drop of argan oil or even castor oil before I apply it if ever I decide to use it as a eyeshadow primer.
Overall I love these ones and would definitely recommend anyone buying them.

I bought this in Pomegranate Punk. It's a really gorgeous, unique shade for the price.
Because it's a cream shadow, I definitely have to apply primer before using this. I also like to use a little base of NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk beforehand, which really helps make this shade stand out more.
With primer (and when I use a bit of Milk as well) this stays put on my eyes for the whole day. It might smudge a tiny bit after a few hours, but nothing too bad.
The texture of Pomegranate Punk is pretty smooth, and if it gets a little bit clumpy it's very easy to blend it out with your fingers or a brush. I like applying this as a liner with my gel liner brush, but I've also used it all over my lid which is pretty gorgeous.
It takes some experimentation to see what technique works best to apply this product. I'm still figuring it out, but so far I prefer applying this shadow by hand (unless I'm using it as a liner obviously). It seems like it blends out better, and I get better control with how much colour I want to pack on.

I found these hard to apply and sometimes chunky rather than smooth to apply

Amazing product and really stays on for 24h.

Great high impact color but it doesn't last more than a few hours.

This product is fantastic! I have oily eyelids and it does not crease. definitely high quality for a drugstore brand.