I'm a big fan of Maybelline mascaras to begin with - I found this to be a pretty good one. It definitely competes with lash stilletto in terms of length but not shine. No clumps which is great...however I do find that because it is a fibre mascara it flakes off quite a bit.

This mascara gave me some length but not enough to be amazing. I did not experience clumping which is good. But my lashes looked thin and it flaked. I would not buy this again.

I found that this mascara worked well for lengthening my lashes but I had to put on another mascara to thicken them. But I would still buy this again

Not quite illegal lengths, but did give a bit of length! I decided to try this new to me mascara as it was on for a great price and I had a coupon so I picked up two. I ended up having to give one away even though the mascara worked as an average mascara would my eyes were left irritated and feeling as though I had sand in my eyes so therefore no I cannot recommend this mascara

This is a relatively OK mascara. It lengthened a bit, but nothing too dramatic. It was too liquidy to offer any volume. I wasn't overly impressed with this mascara. "Average" is the perfect word when describing this mascara. It doesn't volume or lengthen more than a dollar store mascara would. I really didn't like the brush, I found it too soft and pliable. I prefer a hard mascara brush that pushes against my lashes and coats them better. I have to use a business card (or something equally hard) behind my lash line when applying with this wand.

I bought it from Walmart for about $10, and really, it wasn't worth the $10. This mascara would have received a thumbs up if the price was about $3 or so.

The one pro about this formula is it left my lashes soft and not hard or crumbly. It didn't do anything major for me, I wouldn't recommend this only because there are other better alternatives out there (such as Maybelline define-a-lash).

I didn't think I would actually like this mascara, but it's honestly a contender for loyal purchasing! I notice a big difference in length when I use it and I like that it doesn't flake or clump my eyelashes together.

I also really like the wand itself. The brush is long, easy to use and it's really light. I had a coupon for this product as well and found it on sale at Wal Mart so it was a steal but normally at it's $10 price point, I would definitely buy it.

The one thing I don't like is that I find that while it elongates, it doesn't so much give volume or thicken my lashes so I like to add a coat of Lash Blast on top of this for big, long standout lashes.

I very love this mascara! This mascara make natural and no mess! Very awesome product! it realy make lash longer!

I really like this mascara! I wasn't sure I wanted to pay approx. $10 for a mascara I hadn't tried yet, but as it turns out, it was a good purchase.

I find it goes on smoothly, no clumps and really does lengthen my lashes. It dries pretty fast too, so I curl my lashes before I put it on and the curl holds. Since it dries quickly, I don't have to worry about little black dots on my eyelids either!

Wearing black mascara is my usual, especially wearing glasses, but this blackest black stands out even more than I expected.

This will definitely be a regular in my make up stash now.

I had a 3.00 off coupon for Maybelling products and I notice the Illegal Lengths Mascara on sale so I thought I would give it a try. It was truely amazing, keeping in mind that I usually only buy the cheaper mascara. I have never see my eyelashed define so well. I will purchase this again. I absousutely love it.

I had high expectations for this mascara. Fiber extensions?? Longest lashes ever?? Not for me. Even though it didn't prove to be the best mascara for me, others may have different experiences with it. I don't use a eyelash curler, so that may work better with this product. Overall, the mascara is not sticky, no weird smell, easy to remove and no flakies.
I am going to stick to my old best friend: Maybelline Falsies mascara.