One of the worst mascaras I've ever used. I have naturally thick, long eyelashes and this just clumped them up. You need a ton of the colour side just to cover the white, and it ends up clumping and flaking like A LOT. On top of that, it was really sticky, ran onto my cheeks even though it was supposed to be waterproof and was exceedingly difficult to get off. I pulled off many an eyelash when I was scrubbing trying to get this useless product off.

Must say I'm definitely not a fan of this Mascara. I've tried a lot of different mascaras and this one really doesn't live up to its claim. Doesn't make my lashes any more 'thicker or longer' than others I've tried. Not worth the money..or time!

The Mabelline NY XXL Volume & Length Mascara sounds like a really good idea, but really, it just ends up feeling like a lot of work! My eye lashes didn't really look that much thicker and they definately were not longer. Over all, I was not really happy with this product. I didn't end up using it for a very long time because it was just too much work for a big fat nothing effect. I'll just stick to my regular mascaras, thanks.

I have tried many mascaras that have the primer with the mascara. I didn't like this one, I found that the white primer mixed with the mascara turned my eyelashes grey. There wasn't much XXL volume either, the primer was quite useless. A good duo mascara is L'Oreal Double Extend, it really does extend those lashes!

While this mascara did give me voloume, the application was very tricky, it smeared a lot on my upper lid and the content was a bit too gloopy and liquidy for me. It also clumps the lashes together, but if you manage to surpass all these complications, you get lashes with a lot of voloume. If you have prominent eyelids you could pull of this mascara, whereas for me, my eyelids are undefined so this mascara doesn't really do it for me.

This is great!!! It makes your lashes so long and stays on for a realllly long time. I once had something in my eye and I forgot about it and rubbed it...it didn't come off! Also if you want even more intense lashes, get the XXL in the black, red and white container. It lengthens then even more! It's very waterproof...doesn't come off unless you rub realllly hard with water or use eye makeup remover.