great value, great staying power

I love this eyeliner as it feels like a high quality purchase but its super cheap. this eyeliner has a good depth and stays on all day without smudging - I'm a huge fan!

This is the eyeliner I have been looking for all my life. I was able to easily apply it, I love the shape of it. I was able to create different looks with it, which was amazing. It was long lasting, not running (even the next morning AKA raccoon eyes) I would like to try in another colour

There is nothing wrong with the actually eyeliner itself, just merely the shape. The shape makes it very difficult to apply and the end result is usually smudgy and uneven. The product does not last very long, and wears off or rubs off easily. I much prefer liquid or pencil liners.

This eyeliner works wonderfully and beutifully accents your eyes and goes on easy unlike other eyeliners which are hard to get on and barly show. However this eyeliner is great and would go perfectly in any womans makeup collection :)

This is fantastic, great for a smokey look on the lower lash line, goes on smoothly..and stays in place all day.

So had to apply. You can't draw a thin line because it's too big. The idea was nice, but i prefer regular eyeliners.

Tried the Onyx Rush tone, which is basically black. Only suited for drawing thick lines and inner eye line. Does smudge a bit after a few hours of use. A bit difficult for me to keep the tip the same shape as it was when I first bought it, since Maybelline states that you don't have to sharpen it.

I like the longevity and darkness of the liner, but the tip is too thick to get a precise line like I like.

I got this product during the Target blowout sale for half price. It is probably the weirdest looking eye liner I have ever owned. It works pretty good though. I liked how I have the option of applying a thin line or a thicker line by how I hold the product. I like how it came in a variety of different colours.

This is a great eyeliner that comes in many colors and goes on smoothly.