Disaster

I was so incredibly disappointed with this product! I bought it because it looked like the same packaging as the mascara I love so so much. Unfortunately after applying multiple layers, it still barely showed up, yet clumped in my eyelashes, completely defeating the purpose of my amazing non-clumping mascara. I don't like to spend too much on makeup, so I was anxious about spending $10+ on an eyeliner, and my concerns were justified. After all that it only lasted me about 1-2 months, so even if it was good quality, it's way too much money for just a couple months of use.