This product goes on smoothly, the smudge part I find isn't stiff enough but the eyeliner pencil part works great which is the good side of it. You get what you pay for with this product.

This eyeliner is wonderful. I always seem to have the problem of my eyeliner falling when i apply it and wear it for several hours, but that does not happen with this.I highly recommend you try this out for yourself!

Best I've ever used. Little more expensive but need very little and lasts forever. No running or smudging. Will buy again for sure.