Slightly clumpy but definitley thickens the lashes. Cannot let it dry between layers (I like to put on 2 or 3 normally) as it dries quickly and again, clumps.

This mascara is did not work very well for me and just kind of clumped on my sparse, straight, short asian lashes. It definitely did thicken them but I got the "tarantula legs" effect. Maybe that had do with the fact that I don't really have many lashes to separate/coat? I didn't really enjoy the smell either. However, It's not bad enough where I need to immediately replace it with a new one.

I'm giving this mascara average because the cost is typical drug store, and the quality and effectiveness - in this case I am going to have to say its probably more of a personal preference thing, and maybe someone with thicker lashes would benefit from it more.

The mascara tended to clump after continuous use. Work well for a while but not an everyday mascara i would recommend.

Worked okay for the first week and gave me "volume". However, it became a pain to separate my eyelashes with such a thick layer of clumpy mascara the more i used it. Not worth the price unless you are okay with constantly replacing your makeup.

I thought it worked well for the price, but didn't add as much volume as I expected. Also tended to clump...

i bought this product and at first it worked amazingly, it really made my lashes look thick and beautiful. But after a week my eyes started getting dry and uncomfortable by the end of the day. After i washed all my makeup off for the evening i noticed that i had black flakes all over my eyes and contacts from the mascara just slowly flaking off throughout the day; since i already have suuuper dry eyes from wearing contacts this is definatly not something im willing to deal with if i dont have to. Definatly not going to continue using this.

Tried this mascara out from all of the reviews about it here on the site. It's ranked in the Top 10 but I'm really not sure why. Unfortunately this mascara is just ok. I've never had a mascara make my lashes look...what's the word...crunchy? It's like my lashes don't flow together and look pretty, they instead go all over the place, and look like strange different lengths. Super weird and very difficult to describe! And above all else it flakes like crazy! I've never seen that happens nearly as much as this one. Just awful. All of this combined will make me never try this mascara again.

I mean, Maybelline generally has wonderful mascaras, but this one failed the test for me. It was lumpy, bumpy and crunchy. Just TERRIBLE. Plus the rose fragrance additive, hurt my eyes. However, that could be my over active imagination. The only good thing was the price, which was wasted still.

When I first used it it looked and worked great, lashes had more definition and lift. But a week later it started to clump on my lashes and thickened, harder to apply because the brush keeps alot of "goop" on it. Disappointed.

When using this Mascara you can't apply it more than a couple of times or it will really really clump and pieces will end up all over your face. With that being said I used a good formula mascara to coat my lashes and put a coat of this to really boost my lashes!